The Essayist's Notebook

Ad hoc notes on essayism as method.

The FAQ     Search

To speak from certainty requires only a grid; to speak from fidelity requires a threshold.

I have slowly arrived at the view that when Montaigne claims to write de bonne foi, he is not offering a guarantee of accuracy, but a pledge of presence. He is acknowledging that the landscape of human experience is volatile, shifting beneath our feet like the allegiances of this Gascon village.

Yet, by planting his feet in that very instability, foi ceases to be an unbending dogma and becomes a structural pivot. It is the agreement that we may not know the end of the sentence, or the resolution of the chord, but we will remain true to the trajectory of the movement.

Which is to say that foi becomes the foundation on which a man may speak honestly about uncertainty

I have already made this exploration, pulled at this thread, tested this thought. Still it keeps moving. But it has given me something that I wish to try and share. I am not sharing an answer only the experience of the return from the surface.

1. Voice

Open with voice, not technology. Not style. Not vocabulary. Not literary manner. Voice is the self in relation to the world. Explore voice as disposition. Curious. Sceptical. Affectionate. Patient. Combative. A voice is not what we think. It is how we stand in relation to experience. Then move gently into confidence. Where does confidence in voice come from? Not certainty. Not authority. My own experience: • speaking publicly • radio • television • print Confidence came from confidence in the message. But confidence in the message came from believing the words were honest. Don't labour this; just plant it.

2. What Threatens a Voice?

What causes a voice to become uncertain? Ridicule. Audience anticipation. Performance. Fashion. The temptation to become a character. A distinction emerges: A message can survive contradiction. A voice can be undermined by self-consciousness. Perhaps introduce the idea that modern platforms expose voice to judgement before it has fully formed. But keep this secondary. The essay is still about voice, not technology.

3. Contradiction

The heart of the essay. Voice is not certainty. In fact, certainty often produces voices that sound strangely alike. Emerson, Orwell, Nietzche. What puts words on the page? Not answers. Contradictions. The writer discovers that they think several things simultaneously. The world presents itself in contradictions. So does the self. This is where my own experience enters. For years I have found myself returning not to solutions but to contradictions. Not because I enjoy uncertainty. Not because I doubt everything. Because contradiction is where understanding begins.

4. Contradiction as Passage

This is where my imagery lives. Most people encounter contradiction as an obstacle. I encounter it as a route. The cleft in the hill. The passage to the col. Or: Scaffolding. Contradictions expose the structure of an idea, institution, belief or social construction. They reveal where things join. Where the load is carried. Where history has become solid. I trust contradiction because it is difficult to fake. It is often where reality pushes back. A key sentence somewhere around here: The contradictions are not flaws in the system. They are the means by which we move through it. And then: Every going beyond one contradiction brings us insight into another. This is probably the deepest point in the essay. It might be worth noting: Hazlitt often begins with self. Young often begins with observation. My essayism seems to begin with a relationship between the two.

5. Surface

Only now arrive at the title. The notebook. The desk. The Surface. The phone. The platform. Each offers a different surface upon which voice may appear. But no surface is neutral. Some encourage exploration. Some encourage performance. Some favour reflection. Some favour reaction. The question is no longer what voice is. The question becomes: What conditions allow a voice to remain itself?

6. Return to Voice

Circle back. A voice is not a conclusion. A voice is not certainty. A voice is not even consistency. A voice is a continuing relationship between a self and a world that resists simplification. The writer inhabits contradiction not temporarily but perpetually. The exploration never ends because each insight reveals another horizon. The wound remains exposed

7. Ending

Very quiet. No answer. Something close to: Perhaps that is why the search for a voice never really ends. What puts words on the page is not certainty but the effort to understand how the self stands in relation to a world that continually resists simplification. Then one final turn: In an age of endless platforms, audiences and surfaces, I wonder whether the question is no longer how we find a voice, but how we create the conditions in which it can remain itself. Stop. No explanation. No moral. No “therefore”. Leave the reader standing at the col looking into the next valley. That's where the essay really ends.

How does a human being write honestly in conditions of uncertainty?

Originally arising from this note: On the mimicry of uncertianty This note explores the notion of the anchor point within an essay. You will need to have read the above note if you want to make sense of my repeating references to the Fagor washing machine

George Orwell

A good example, and one I think resonates strongly with what I'm calling an anchor point, comes from Orwell's essay “A Hanging” (1931). The essay is moving through questions of empire, punishment, power and death, but the entire moral weight of the piece pivots on a tiny observation: the condemned man steps aside to avoid a puddle on the way to the gallows.

It is a trivial act. Yet Orwell suddenly apprehends that this is not an abstract category called “a prisoner” but a living human being with a life of purposes and habits. The puddle becomes an “anchor point” from which the essay's moral perception unfolds.

The essay does not begin with a thesis about capital punishment. It begins with experience. The recognition emerges from attention. Similarly, in “Shooting an Elephant”, the elephant itself becomes an anchor point. Orwell is ostensibly discussing imperialism, but the essay turns on the concrete predicament of standing before the animal with a rifle while a crowd watches. The imperial system becomes legible through a single lived situation.

What is interesting for our purposes is that these early Orwell essays are full of what Essayism would probably regard as legitimate anchor points:

a puddle, an elephant, a cup of tea, a coal miner descending a shaft, a toad appearing in spring.

They are encountered things. The thought grows out of them. When I write about the washing machine, Ludwig Gann, Fagor and Mondragon, I believe I am doing something structurally very similar. I am not presenting evidence to support an existing argument. I am recording the point at which the world itself begins to disclose a connected thread. Where my critique of the “later” Orwell may emerge is that these anchor points gradually seem less capable of sponsoring possibility and more capable of sponsoring diagnosis.

To put it differently: Early Orwell: “This thing I have observed unsettles my assumptions.” Later Orwell: “This thing I have observed confirms my opinions.” That may be putting it too sharply, but I think it is close to the distinction that is now pacing the trackways in my thoughts.

In my note, the washing machine functions very much like Orwell's puddle in A Hanging. It is utterly mundane. Yet from it unfold questions of technology, co-operation, labour, memory, place, intellectual formation, cynicism and essayism itself. The difference is that my washing machine anchor point leads to an expansion of possibility and connection, whereas the argument I am beginning to formulate about AI and perhaps the later (Animal Farm) Orwell is that both exhibit a tendency toward closure. They arrive at the answer too quickly.

That, I think, is why the line in my note: It seemed entirely ordinary then. is important. It is the moment before the anchor point reveals itself as an anchor point. I would like to believe that sentence carries the same quality as Orwell noticing a man step around a puddle. The meaning has not yet arrived, but it is about to.

William Hazlitt

For me, personally as an Essayist, Hazlitt reveals more because Hazlitt's anchor points are often absurdly ordinary and personal. He does not begin with public questions and descend to experience. He begins in experience and discovers that it contains the world.

The classic example is “On Going a Journey.” The anchor point is simply walking. Not a philosophy of walking. Not a theory of solitude. Just setting out on a road. Everything else unfolds from that act. Hazlitt notices a signpost, a distant hill, an inn, a stream, a stretch of road. The essay's reflections on freedom, society, memory and consciousness arise from those encounters. The walk is not an illustration of the argument. The walk generates the argument. That feels very close to my washing machine passage.

Now as I think about this, I must report an observation of a friend: I suspect your own work is actually closer to Young than you sometimes admit. When you talk about writing as “walking the landscape in words”, that's not quite Hazlitt. Hazlitt's landscape often becomes a theatre for consciousness. Your landscape often has an independent reality that pushes back.

Hazlitt often begins with self. Young often begins with observation. Your Essayism seems to begin with a relationship between the two. Neither the Romantic tendency: What does this reveal about me? Nor the purely descriptive tendency: What is out there? But rather: What happens when an attentive mind encounters this thing? That is why the washing-machine passage works. It isn't really a memoir passage. It isn't really a descriptive passage. It is a record of an encounter. The machine leads to Gann. Gann leads to Leicester. Leicester leads to Mondragon. Mondragon leads to Orwell. Orwell leads to uncertainty. – OK I paraphrased his comments.

But to return to Hazlitt and his anchor points – Another excellent example is On the Pleasure of Hating. The anchor point is astonishingly small. He sits at a coach window watching people gather around a travelling show. From this observation of a crowd his thoughts begin ranging across politics, prejudice, conflict, partisanship and human nature. Again, the anchor point is concrete and observed.

Even closer to what I am trying to describe might be My First Acquaintance with Poets. The ostensible subject is literary, but the essay repeatedly anchors itself in specific remembered encounters: seeing Coleridge walk into a room, hearing him speak, the atmosphere of the place, the impressions of the young Hazlitt. The essay is not organised around a thesis concerning Romanticism. It is organised around recollected moments. What I see here for my developing notions areound Essayism is that Hazlitt's anchor points often remain open.

Orwell's puddle in A Hanging ultimately points toward a conclusion about capital punishment. Hazlitt's best anchor points often continue radiating associations long after they have performed their immediate function. Take the opening impulse of On Going a Journey. The walk never quite becomes reducible to a lesson. It remains a walk. The physical experience never entirely disappears beneath interpretation.

I'd like to believe that's close to what my washing machine is doing. The machine is not merely “evidence” for a proposition about essayism. It remains stubbornly itself: a machine, Ludwig Gann, Leicester, Fagor, Mondragon, ICOM, laundry before a flight. The associations accumulate, but none annihilates the reality of the thing itself.

In reviewing the washing machine a number of things occur to me. It is much more of a Hazlittian anchor than an Orwellian one. Orwell's anchor points often become moral revelations. Hazlitt's anchor points become occasions for associative exploration. And I wrote it naturally, it was not a contrived device, it was the simple emergence of my disposition on to the page.

And there is perhaps a useful formulation lurking there for Essayism: An anchor point is an ordinary encounter that proves incapable of remaining ordinary. The puddle in Orwell. The road in Hazlitt. The washing machine in Montory. None is introduced as a symbol. Each becomes one only because prolonged attention reveals a network of relations hidden within the mind of the person perceiving it.

That, I suspect, is precisely what my AI critique is saying. The machine can imitate the shape of the anchor point, but it tends to arrive carrying the conclusion already folded inside it. Hazlitt, at his best, genuinely does not know where the road will lead when he sets out along it. The uncertainty is not decorative. It is generative.

Addendum: On the mimicry of uncertianty

Washing dried, flight over, sat at my desk in a different location carrying the seeds of a different stance, I re-read the piece I wrote above.

I have written before on Defining Sentences that device that literary critics (and AI too now it seems) love to use; to identify a phrase or a sentence to which they can point and declare “this is what the story, essay, polemic, whatever, revolves around. And I have explained my own rebellious nature and how I seek to de-focus this. Because it is one thing to be focussed in the written expression of the thought. But that does not mean that the thought itself is focussed. And that very lack of focus needs to be protected. There is frequently a reason for it. Even now I know there is another note destined to follow this on “Anchor Points”.

Never-the-less I am nothing if not an essayist and must confirm that the first person educated (if I may use the word) by my writing, is me. So today I walked back through the note on “the mimicry of uncertainty” and here is what I found:

The note is not about AI trawling my work, but about intellectual honesty and the apparent performance of it. That's why Orwell entered my head so readily, occupying my attention because he represents a competing account of what intellectual honesty looks like when confronted by disappointment.

Orwell has been much on my mind lately, not because I disagree with his commitment to honesty, but because I am increasingly persuaded that disappointment can masquerade as honesty. To lose faith in a possibility because one has witnessed its failure is not necessarily realism. It may simply be another form of injury. An essayist must remain open to what remains unresolved. As I have written elsewhere there is always value in negative results

The whole piece seems to revolve around this: It remains an unresolved ache. The whole piece appears to turn on that idea. Elsewhere I say ...to endure a life of open wound and not collapse into cynicism. That feels like one of the underlying propositions of Essayism. The cynic closes the wound. The essayist keeps it open. Not because suffering is noble, but because closure too quickly becomes blindness. The essayist remains susceptible to surprise, disappointment, contradiction, wonder and connection. There is a cost to that susceptibility, but there is also insight.

The machine cannot live with an unresolved ache. The road-layer must pave it. The formulaic essay must convert it into a takeaway. The cynic must explain it away. The essayist, by contrast, carries it forward.

That's why I suspect Orwell and the AI essay ultimately occupy the same place in my argument. Both are, in different ways, examples of the urge to escape uncertainty. One escapes through disenchantment, the other through optimisation. The essayist's task is to remain present to it.

Overall, the note reveals something rather interesting: my criticism of AI is not primarily technological. It is ontological. The machine's failure is not that it lacks information. It lacks a lived history through which one thing unexpectedly becomes another thing. It cannot stand beside a washing machine and find Leicester, Mondragon, worker ownership, Orwell and the nature of essayism already waiting there.

That, I think, is the deeper argument beginning to emerge beneath the surface of this possible essay.

So the Notebook is becoming more than the sum of its parts. (Now my brain is off exploring the quintessential. STOP! Get back to the task in hand.)

When I began, I was simply looking for a friction-free surface where I might assemble a few notes on Essayism, in public. The first reason was that, after more than a decade or two of essaying, I had finally given myself permission to describe my disposition publically, as that of an essayist. The second was that there is a peculiar accountability in sharing one's thoughts with others. I “own” them. I become much more attentive to the care with which I express them. It sharpens my performance of good faith. The words chosen better represent the thought than the sloppy scribble in a Moleskine while sitting at the back of a bus.

In the early days, I found my posts attracting three or four readers. So I did not distress myself when I returned to a note to amend it or add an addendum. It did not seem significant. Now it has become a habit. And I was about to make a significant amendment to an early post when I noticed that my posts now receive anything between 150 and 200 readers. Should the quantity of readers matter? Probably not. But the notion of repeatedly presenting an incomplete thought has nagged at me a little. So, some changes.

1: There is now a FAQ. If you have arrived here recently, you can now take a look at a few short paragraphs that I hope address the inquiries of curious minds as to what I am doing here.

2: I've created a Google search box. The menu item for it sits both in the header, alongside the FAQ, and in the footer. At the moment, the search incorporates both this site, The Essayist's Notebook, and the wider Essayism.org. At some point in the near future I may have to separate them. But the point is that, for now, you can type in a keyword, a concept, or a fragment of a title and probably find something somewhere across the two sites.

3: Amendments and Updates. This is a significant structural change, and the search option facilitates it well. Rather than add to, or silently expand, an existing note, I will create a new note that links to the original. It will flow into the wider broadcast mechanism and readers such as yourself will be alerted: there has been an update to the thought.

That's it. A bit of housekeeping that shows some courtesy to you, the reader, whom I have to thank for providing the accountability I was seeking.

A disturbing development has arrived on the digital horizon: the algorithmic standardization of the essai.

I came across a piece of writing today titled: What Is a Literary Essayist? (And Why I Decided to Become One) July 20, 2026

Yes, of course I am going to read something with that title and yes, I am going to be eager to get to it. But this is the first day with sunshine in over a week and I'm grabbing the chance to put a wash on. I'm catching a flight tomorrow and if I don't leave the house tidy there will be some non-literary frictions I will have to navigate. As a result my engagement with the piece was somewhat stoccato. This may have been a benefit.

The washing machine itself is almost an essay in the making. This particular model uses a system invented by Ludwig Gann whom I met when I was studying at Leicester University. And it's made by Fagor, a champion of the Mondragon movement I was to encounter only a year or two later. At the time I was working with the Industrial Common Ownership Movement in Britain, funded by the British state to explore forms of worker ownership and democratic enterprise. There I saw at first hand that workers' movements were capable not merely of protest but of institution-building. The later lessons of their successes and failures stayed with me long after many commentators, Orwell among them, had ceased to believe such projects could endure. It seemed entirely ordinary then. Only later did I realize how improbable it was that the threads of a Basque co-operative, a Leicester inventor, a washing machine in rural France and my own dispostion as an essayist should all end up knotted together in the same domestic moment.

I'm exploring all of this in my thoughts as I fill the tub with soiled clothes. You see, it's about the ever-presence of connections and the cost of remaining open to them. The essayist must endure a life of open wound and resist the temptation of cynicism. I don't realize it yet, but I am already engaged with the essay – or at least the things about the essay title that give me pause, and I haven't even read the first paragraph. It's this phrase “And Why I Decided to Become One”. It has me stopped cold. It isn't wrong. It's just contrary to my whole life experience. I've written a few pieces lately on what it means to be an essayist, a literary essayist in particular. It was never a choice. It is the way I am. And I think the explorations here and in The Essayist and Essayism demonstrate that. The move was not to decide to become an essayist, but to prefer the title of the disposition over that of the job. I'm a journeyman writer by trade and an essayist by disposition. The first I could choose. The second was an accident of birth, and it remains an unresolved ache.

The Tarmac Methodology

The machine is a master road-layer. It looks at the jagged, uneven terrain of an inquiry and immediately seeks to level it, to make it passable for the casual commuter. It cannot tolerate a sentence that hesitates, or a thought that trips over its own roots. In doing so, this algorithmic smoothness directly betrays the heritage of Baldwin and Didion. Where Baldwin forced us to feel the heavy, vertical pressure of Harlem’s masonry and Didion mapped the cold, horizontal vacuum of the California sprawl, they did so by rejecting the easy alibis of advocacy and pre-packaged conclusions. They stood on the hot, fractured pavement of a public crisis and used the raw, unshielded movement of private perception to make chaos legible. This new optimized writing does the exact opposite: it turns the terrifying fluidities of genuine inquiry into a uniform gravel driveway, selling a decorative map to a landscape the machine has never actually walked.

The ultimate exposure of this tarmac methodology arrived a week later in a follow-up piece where she laid out her process. She reduced the dynamic, unpredictable choreography of thinking to a rigid framework of exactly “seven movements.”

This is where the copy ceases to be faithful to human experience and becomes faithful only to an algorithmic recipe. Generative AI is remarkably adept at mimicking the appearance of a search, but its code is inherently hostile to the very thing that makes an essay an essay: unmanageable uncertainty. An LLM can mimic the language of an unresolved ache, but it cannot inhabit one. Its weights and biases are tuned to solve, to compress, and to deliver a neat, shareable takeaway.

The same instinct appears elsewhere in human behaviour. AI has merely been trained to replicate it. I have a lamp in my parlour, placed on a table, atop a pile of books, to facilitate reading by anyone who occupies the adjacent armchair. It is the antithesis of the way an interior designer places a statement lamp: not to see by, but to be seen seeing. Such is the structured performance of vulnerability, dropping names like Jung or Maté.

Branding Pivot

To choose “essayist” as a branding pivot is to treat the form as an exogenous costume rather than an endogenous honesty. When you write with a prompt to steady your shovel, you are no longer digging where you stand. You are letting a machine level the ground before you even begin the trial.

The essay remains a living tool for public utility and self-examination precisely because it risks the total failure of its own premise. It is a sequence of hesitations, reversals, and small experiments in meaning that survive only because they encounter the unshielded conscience of the person writing them.

As the Fagor cycle hums toward its final spin in the laundry room, and I look at my half-packed bag for tomorrow's flight, and the vacuum cleaner still awaiting it's duty cycle, I am reminded of why we must guard the rough track. The task of the essayist is not to build a smooth, decorative path for an audience. But to lead them through the landscape we have begun to explore.

For this reason, after writing the critique of Orwell's contribution to essayism, for essayism.org, he has been much on my mind. Was my criticism justified. Not because I disagree with his commitment to honesty, but because I am increasingly persuaded that disappointment can masquerade as honesty. To lose faith in a possibility because one has witnessed its failure is not necessarily realism. It may simply be another form of injury. An essayist must remain open to what remains unresolved.

In this sense, the algorithm and the cynic are unexpected allies to each other. One cannot tolerate uncertainty because it has been trained to resolve it. The other cannot tolerate uncertainty because he has been wounded by it. Both seek shelter in premature conclusions. The essayist has no such refuge. The task is not to eliminate uncertainty, but to accompany it.

Perhaps now, the task is to find out what can still be believed after the language has broken against the reality of a life. We must protect that brokenness from the automated formula. If we don’t, we aren't writing essays at all; we are just content creators wearing a dead man's title, selling maps to landscapes we never actually walked.

To democratize the essay means stripping away academic gatekeeping and returning to its radical, foundational core: the act of “digging where you stand.” Becoming an essayist does not require an exhaustive literary pedigree or an elite reading list. It requires the raw, accessible willingness to accurately map your own position in the world, writing de bonne foi (in good faith), and maintaining total fidelity to the architecture of your own thoughts.

By shifting the barrier to entry from exogenous knowledge (what you have read) to endogenous honesty (what you perceive), the craft becomes available to anyone with a vantage point.

The most convincing argument for democratising the essay came from mature women in my university classrooms. Sent there by their trade unions, often after years spent raising children, caring for family members and balancing work with responsibility, they arrived with a deep knowledge of everyday life. The union representative role gave them permission to speak publicly, but it did not give them insight. They already possessed that. Doreen, Eileen, Siobhán, Marie and Joan understood the texture of ordinary experience and could command the language of daily life with remarkable precision. What they lacked was not capability but permission: permission to treat their own attention as worthy of sustained inquiry. Once that permission was granted, the essay became available to them.

In this note I'm thinking about how I reconstruct the path to becoming an essayist for these women and men and women like them.

There are three democratic pillars

1: Dig Where You Stand

• The immediate landscape is the primary text. You do not need to look outward for grand, abstract themes to be worthy of writing. • Vantage over pedigree. Every inquiry begins exactly where your feet meet the ground – your specific memory, your local contradiction, or your immediate observation. • Radical accessibility. If you are alive and paying attention to your environment, you already possess the necessary raw material.

2: Operating with Good Faith – De Bonne Foi

• The Montaigne accord. Honoring the classic pact that the text is an honest, unvarnished mirror of a human mind. • Relinquishing performative authority. Writing without a hidden agenda, political posture, or the need to sound like an “expert.” • Visible limitations. Acknowledging your own biases, history, and blind spots as part of the narrative landscape.

3: Fidelity to the Mind's Movement

• Accurate internal reporting. Capturing a thought as it actually occurs, rather than how it should look to satisfy an audience or an editor. • Preserving the mess. Resisting the temptation to tidy up intellectual contradictions or uncertainties just to manufacture a clean conclusion. • The text as a dynamic record. Treating writing as a mirror of an evolving mind in motion, rather than a monument to a settled opinion.

This philosophical shift turns the essay back into a living tool for public utility and self-discovery, rather than a cloistered literary exercise.

rvw.ie t-line signature panel David Marshall Montory

If an essayist's primary obligation is fidelity to the inquiry, then one must be willing to encounter something true or useful wherever it appears.

The essayist's task is not merely to notice what is broken or uncertain. It is also to recognise those rare moments when the world quietly discloses that things are, for now, enough.

Enter your email to subscribe to updates.